ewancummins wrote:Are you using the monk class or the battle dancer (from Dragon Magazine- converted to D20 in the Dragon Compendium)?
That has still to be dealt with the DM

I am considering a straight monk, with replacement of some abilities. I've taken a look at that class and these are my views:
Pros:
- fighter bab progression
- attack based class features
Cons:
- worse saves than monk
- still insufficient AC bonus for a front-row fighter
- less skills
- no bonus feats as Monk did
- no evasion
- no flurry of blows (it gets better towards the end)
So, about the only good thing I see in the Battle Dancer is the BAB. I'm not sure this is enough to justify a chance.
On the other hand, I've read somewhere that the monk was poorly thought-out as a class because it had self-defeating features. Don't remind which.
For all this, I'll be proposing some changes to the original monk and consider that as a 3rd viable option.