Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:Heh... "Younger" players play 5th now. You're a bit out of date.Resonant Curse wrote:Generally the older (35+ish) crowd that started with the older editions prefer the slower pace and generally all have set homes/jobs, which does lend itself to longer campaigns that can last decades. Younger players tend to have started on 3rd/tail end of second computer games like Baldur's Gate and are used to the faster 3rd+ speed. The faster speed is better suited for the high school/college crowd that can't necessarily expect their friends or even themselves not to have moved out of the area any given semester/year.
Generally, people tend to play what they grew up with. Switching editions is a huge undertaking and only gets worse as you get older and set in your ways.
We get a lot of 3.5/PF here because that's the edition of the last major setting. We also get some 2e players because that was where RL started. The more adventurous among us have branched into 4e and 5e, but many just stick with what they know.
(42-year-old 3.5/Pathfinder DM here... Campaign running through 28 weekend long sessions over the past 16 years, going from 1st level (3.0) to 11th (PF) so far, with no end in sight...)
I meant anything post 3rd edition by 3+. I certainly wasn't saying that there aren't a ton of fantastic 3/pathfinder/5th games run or played by the group around for when 2nd or older editions were the norm. I know a player in the 2nd edition game I am a player in at the moment (I prefer 3/3.5 myself due to the easier customization for players and dms even of monsters) that is dming a 5th edition game. It sounds like it is a great campaign, unfortunately it falls on one of the days I have my daughter so I can't participate. I was more saying that *generally* the older players are a lot more into the slow grind play style that 2nd edition had and requires tweaking of experience a lot more for later editions to accomplish. The Ravenloft setting does lend itself to a bit slower xp gain too since it tends to have somewhat fewer combats.