Matthew L. Martin wrote:Matthew L. Martin wrote:But Azalin would probably have found himself irked by this move of S's, since he wouldn't be able to get her back to fulfill his real plans for her.
Hmm...I may have let slip more than I intended there.
How annoying is it when you blatantly drop a hint like that, only to find out that people like myself had missed it completely?
Take heart, though: as Mangrum pointed out, most of us (myself included) are unable to actually listen to the hints you guys give out, instead hearing what we want to hear. Meaning, you've definitely not given any hint to me, anyway...
For example: what I think you said (trying my best not to hear what I want to hear, but just what was said), "S doesn't make it back home after Gaz XIII, and it's due to purposeful actions of S's." Only you and the Kargatane (and maybe a few others) know whether I heard your hint right or not. Most likely I got it wrong, further strengthening Mangrum's argument. And even if I got it right, considering how often we all read these hints incorrectly, everyone will simply assume that it was wrong anyway and so it doesn't matter. The secrets are still safe regardless of how many you choose to reveal.
So I wouldn't worry about it, if you did accidentally reveal more than you'd intended.
And in case you're curious, here's what I heard, based on my own story idea from above and Ryan Naylor mentioning S's proposed suicide attempt: "S merges herself into the God-Brain as a way of finally escaping Azalin's grasp and controlling her own life."
Mind you, I'm not predicting that this is the real idea proposed by the Kargatane. Usually Mangrum comes up with these really poetic and complicated ideas (that I love reading but could never create), and so I predict that S's way of escaping Azalin's overarching control would have to somehow symbolize how Azalin would escape the Dark Powers' overarching control OR how Azalin could successfully escape if only he were willing to seek redemption. Example is the whole S committing suicide to be free of Azalin as matched to Azalin more-or-less committing suicide in the Requiem to be free of the Dark Powers, with neither being free in the end. Or, as something that's already written, there's the similarity of S not letting her daughter die, just as Azalin keeps trying to bring Irik back and won't let him rest.
I just put out the ideas that I think of, nothing more, nothing less. It's not Kargatane-quality so it's not a guess at the Kargatane's plot. Or, at least, I shouldn't be guessing at the Kargatane's plot, though I might have done so earlier.
Anyway, point being, there are enough people like me who will purposefully take the hints incorrectly anyway (merging them into our own ideas to make something different than the Kargatane's) that any secrets you accidentally drop will be hidden again pretty quickly. The Kargatane and others in-the-know will realize you dropped a real secret, but the rest of us won't, so who cares?
Matthew L. Martin wrote:The Beast's sidebar was cut for space, unfortunately--this led to them tagging the Dukkars in later Gazs as 'do not cut'.
I realize, as it was in this same thread that it was explained (page 2). It was just a poor joke on my part, that the Beast of the Hills was so unimportant that even the Editors cut her out. My apologies that the joke was too poor to be recognized as such.
Matthew L. Martin wrote:Sorry, but I've got too much respect for the Kargatane to reveal what I know without their go-ahead. You want me to talk, get John to let me off my leash.

If I'd taken the time to think about it, I would have realized that the Kargatane was the source of your knowledge of the Kargatane's plots... And as such wouldn't have made such a silly comment. Sorry about that, as I agree that since they took you into their confidence, it'd be pretty dishonorable to reveal their secrets without their permission. I just wasn't thinking.