Fair criticism (and some love huzzah!). Mileage varies, but that is why I wanted to get folks involved. Reflecitonloft is a concept more than anything else, and can be used as much or as little as necessary for each DM, and should be tailored to them and their campaigns! I'm just trying put down some groundwork.Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:I love the idea. I think maybe your rules about what changes and what doesn't are a little over-complicated and would confuse players.
Ah, that's right! I completely had that over-complicated in my attempts to make structure and simplicity, ha!The Giamarga wrote:Note though that the reflected Tindal is N, while Tindafalus was NE. My theory is that similar to how the elemental planes become tainted while overlapping the demiplane or dread, the demiplane of mirrors is tainted too, so that all reflections do not reflect quite to the good morality, rather stopping at neutral.
More love from folks I respect on here? Fantastic! And that is a very good point. I know I have my own ideas that I can share, and then we can all share our own, but in the end, presenting just a flipped Sithicus (since Tindal starts there, it makes sense that's a good place to start) and Barovia (the iconic location, especially with the 'House of Tindal' idea I threw around).Joël of the FoS wrote:I also love the Tindal mirror domains idea. That is extremely interesting.
However the scope of it is too big. You'll loose people's interest if they have to convert the whole thing to Reflectionloft.
I'd restrain it to a few iconic domains that could be changed to Reflectionloft, and that would be it.
(and perhaps add guidelines on how to convert your preferred domain to Refloft, but do not do the whole thing or you'll never finish!)
Joël
