Mortavius wrote:I love the name of this creature, but I hate the creature itself: the Scavyt. Cool name, but it's a bloody cavern-dwelling hyena. Nothing more. That, and the Razorback. What's gothic or terrifying about a boar? Even one with some spikes on it's shoulders?
I would have gladly ditched both of those creatures as well. I thought the razorback lent itself to unintentional comedy, though I did eventually come around a little and find a niche for it (in Gaz I). The scavyt just struck me as totally generic.
As a note, it was while I was tearing through DoDark that I came to the (much delayed) personal realization that, in 2E, several kinds of Ravenloft elemental (dread elementals in 3E) were, in terms of game mechanics, absolutely identical to the standard varieties.
Since I've been ragging on the book, I should be fair and say that there were critters I really liked as well. The drownings were inventive, for example, and I thought the new wrinkles in the kizoku gave it a much more distinctive flavor. (I'd credit the authors, but other than the Kargatane authors, I don't have much of a clue as who wrote what.)