Page 1 of 1
Curse of Innistrad - anyone tried it?
Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 4:44 am
by Le Noir Faineant
Hey, all!
Question's in the title:
A friend of mine is a super-duper fan of MtG; he has a new kid, and so the rest of us have offered (or rather, "told him") that we want to run some D&D again some time soon. So, there is this idea that we use MtG as a background for the game. Obviously, there are other options out there that might well work: I have since learned that there are some MtG-D&D crossover books out there. Now if I am going to DM, especially more or less "spontaneously", then it got to be something that I really enjoy and (think) I am good at.
So, since Wizbro themselves suggest setting Barovia on the plane of Innistrad --
https://media.wizards.com/2016/dnd/down ... istrad.pdf
-- this seems like the most obvious choice.
Now, apart from briefly playing MtG in high school, some time between "Die Hard 2" and "Die Hard 3", I have no real idea of its lore. The 5e remake of I6, I have read, but do not know intimately.
So, my question goes: What's a good starting point for this? What are your own experiences with "Curse of Innistrad", if any?
My own impression so far is - besides the art, I am not sure how much "Innistrad" would really remain in such a campaign. Yeah, a full conversion might be possible, but the old I6 narrative really doesn't particularly need those additions. I am not sure "Curse of Strahd" was written with "Innistrad" in mind, at all, despite coming out of the same studio.
Cheers,
Rafe
Re: Curse of Innistrad - anyone tried it?
Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 10:58 am
by Strahdsbuddy
Barovia as part of Innistrad? how short-sighted. Just like when i saw it in print the first time a decade ago, i believe surely Stensia, Kessig, Nephalia, and Gavony belong in the Mists! A large core-sized version of this "plane," to use the MtG terminology, would give a great opportunity to a Ravenloft DM whose players know a bit too much lore. I would recommend setting the time during Dark Ascension, with Avacyn imprisoned in the Helvault and the tide turned against humanity. Not quite hopeless, but a definite struggle. Mikaeus still lives and tries to keep the angel's disappearance from becoming public knowledge. You could even play into the physical similarities between Avacyn and Ezra with some mist-traveled anchorites discovering the new realm, but i think Innistrad works best separated from the regular canon. A place to do some more hack-and-slash as events unfold around the party.
Innistrad and Ixalan were part of my brief and intense foray into MtG. To me, they both have homes in the Mists. Innistrad lore was prolific enough that it scratched my Ravenloft itch when there was nothing being officially published by Wizbro. I think it is different enough to stand on its own. It is well-mapped and well-developed and you can have Runo Stromkirk walking among the peasantry or multiple howlpacks tearing them to shreds and still have the feel of the setting, very mist-adjacent.
Re: Curse of Innistrad - anyone tried it?
Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 10:33 am
by Le Noir Faineant
So... How do I do it? Instead of bringing Ravenloft to MtG, I bring Mtg to Ravenloft?
An-Haava Inn, I shall be thy doom!

Re: Curse of Innistrad - anyone tried it?
Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 5:04 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
Think of it as a "second chance" at the Core. What would you do in Verbrek or Tepest that you would need to rewrite a ton of canon to make it work? That's what you do in Kessig. The same in Stensia, a place where Vampires are known and in control, but not named Strahd. Nephalia is more than just Lamordia and Gavony is more than just Mordent with Levkarest in the middle of it.
This would make a fine Gazetteer, there's a ton of lore to draw from. More than we could solve in a weekend, i'd think. Statting Olivia Voldaren (my favorite Commader) is likely easy enough, but like any established setting it can suffer from MERPS syndrome: what do you do if you're not actively moving the story from Dark Ascension to Avacyn Restored? And is that sort of "happy ending" a goal of the story? Alternatively, just making a dent in Geralf and Gisa's war could be fun. Or maybe foiling Ludevic's research before he can hatch the monstrous Gaiju-like creature. I've been righty accused as a DM of being better at running stories than adventures, so i'd leave it to those better than I to mine fore ideas.
For all things MtG, there are better read folks on this board, not least of which is GonzoRon. Should we rally a fey more experts?
Re: Curse of Innistrad - anyone tried it?
Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:36 pm
by Le Noir Faineant
I like the idea - but this would definitely be too much for me. I want to run one specific game, not reinvent the setting. I am positively not particularly interested in MtG; now, there are suggestions from the publisher as to how connect MtG to Ravenloft. If they make no sense, or are bad, I am definitely not the one to fix them.

...But I remain open for suggestions.
My own take, if I went completely DIY-creative, would likely be to tinker on something more straightforward. MtG's "Baron Sengir" from the "Homelands" expansion is basically a pseudo-Dracula like the original version of Strahd. (That I remember "Homelands" dates me in an unflattering light, I guess.) Sengir's backstory is considerably less baroque and convoluted than the backstory Wizbro are offering for Innistrad.
Now, again, I don't want to spend six months writing to run, what, three sessions of D&D. I need a quicker fix. Now, admittedly, there are some apparently pretty good MtG/D&D crossovers out there; no personal opinions on that, I just go by what the review sites seem to indicate. -- Thing is, none of them seem to have any direct proximity to RL; Innistrad has. Really, a bit strange that despite the relative hype that seems to accompany that setting up till today, nobody has written anything substantial for it. ...Say for the DMsG, etc.

...You sound like you have the fire in your belly to tell such a tale; by all means, do.
