I also dug
The Brotherhood of the Wolf, warts and all. As Gonzoron said a while back, it's the closest thing yet to
Ravenloft: The Movie, IMO.
As a huge fan of Hammer Films, I'll recommend the Chris Lee/Dracula movies as well, particularly the first (
Horror of Dracula) and the third (
Dracula Has Risen From the Grave). While the latter isn't Hammer's best film by any means, it's my favorite of all the Hammer films, epitomizing everything about the studio in its heyday. It has blood, drama, terrific cinematography, good score, and amazing cleavage.
Also, while Peter Cushing was indeed
The Man as Dr. Van Helsing, he just as effectively played a complete bastard in Hammer's Frankenstein series, which focused on the doctor, not his creations. Best in that series:
Curse of Frankenstein and
Frankenstein Must Be Destroyed.
And completely coincidentally,
TCM has just released those last four films on one DVD package! I guess TCM thinks those four films are most representative, too.
I'll lastly recommend two lesser-known Hammer films.
Dr. Jekyll and Sister Hyde is, despite the name, one of Hammer's cleverer films and is solidly set in Victorian London. A new DVD release is soon to be available (or already is) in the UK; we in the US are out of luck for a while.
Curse of the Mummy's Tomb is a good movie to watch with friends and the alcoholic beverage of your choice. It has cool gothic atmosphere, multiple instances of overacting, and some outstandingly violent slayings by the mummy.